Table of Contents
Alchemy – Choose Thy Poison Review
Stepping into Alchemy | Choose Thy Poison feels less like entering a restaurant and more like being invited into a carefully staged ritual. The team behind this San Diego gem has built a menu and atmosphere where every cocktail and plate is presented as a small performance, balancing playful experimentation with serious culinary technique. From the moment you arrive the lighting, music, and service work together to create an intimate, slightly mysterious evening that rewards curiosity. (choosethypoison.com)
What truly sets Alchemy apart is its drinks program. The cocktails are inventive and beautifully composed — think punchbowl rituals, smoky pours, and garnishes that double as conversation starters. The site highlights standout dishes such as Aguachile Negro and Tetelas, and images like the Elixir of Life cocktail suggest a menu that pairs bold flavors with thoughtful presentation. Whether you come for a signature cocktail or a shared plate, there’s a real sense of craft in each item. (choosethypoison.com)
The food leans toward comforting yet distinctive flavors; photos of seared ribeye, blue corn tostadas, and grilled shrimp hint at a kitchen that knows how to deliver satisfying textures and bright seasoning. Portions are shareable, encouraging a communal experience that complements the theatrical drinking menu. Reviews quoted on the website praise the flavor combinations, attentive service, and the brunch menu—making it clear that Alchemy works equally well for a weekend meal or a special evening out. (choosethypoison.com)
Atmosphere is a major draw: the outdoor patio with heaters and chandelier lighting is ideal for relaxed date nights and small celebrations, while interior spaces host rotating experiences described on the site as limited-seat events and collaborations. The restaurant also emphasizes private events, catering, and bespoke experiences, so it’s a great option for anyone planning a rehearsal dinner, birthday, or corporate gathering. Practical perks include online ordering and reservations, and the advertised Elixir Hour (4:00–5:30 PM) offers a tempting 50% off during that window. (choosethypoison.com)
In short, Alchemy | Choose Thy Poison feels like a modern neighborhood discovery with the polish of a destination restaurant. With its inventive cocktails, shareable food, inviting patio, and focus on memorable experiences, it’s an easy recommendation for anyone in San Diego seeking something beyond the ordinary. The website lists the address (1932 Kearney Ave, San Diego, CA 92113) and contact information for reservations and inquiries, making it simple to plan a visit. Book ahead, bring friends, and be prepared to let the kitchen and bar surprise you. (choosethypoison.com)
Beyond regular dining, Alchemy promotes special collaborations and one-night-only dinners that turn a meal into an event, and the site encourages inquiries for private parties and catering with bespoke packages tailored to different occasions. The staff contact details (phone and email) are provided online, making planning straightforward whether you need a small rehearsal dinner or a larger catered holiday party. For locals and visitors alike, the combination of theatrical drinking, carefully spiced dishes, and a welcoming, knowledgeable staff makes Alchemy a memorable stop on San Diego’s steadily evolving dining map.
Reserve early; seats and events often sell quickly.
Photos of Alchemy – Choose Thy Poison
Address of Alchemy – Choose Thy Poison
1932 Kearney Ave #100, San Diego, CA 92113, United States
Phone Number of Alchemy – Choose Thy Poison
(619) 635-0287
Website of Alchemy – Choose Thy Poison
Weekday working hours of Alchemy – Choose Thy Poison
Monday: Closed
Tuesday: 11:00 AM – 2:00 PM, 4:00 – 10:00 PM
Wednesday: 11:00 AM – 2:00 PM, 4:00 – 10:00 PM
Thursday: 11:00 AM – 2:00 PM, 4:00 – 10:00 PM
Friday: 11:00 AM – 2:00 PM, 4:00 – 10:00 PM
Saturday: 11:00 AM – 2:00 PM, 4:00 – 10:00 PM
Sunday: 10:00 AM – 3:00 PM
